ClaudevsGPT

Claude Sonnet 5 vs GPT 4.1

Side-by-side comparison of pricing, task quality, and projected cost at higher scale.

Pricing

Side-by-side pricing

Claude Sonnet 5

Mid-tier

GPT 4.1

Mid-tier
Input $/MTok
$2.00
$2.00
Output $/MTok
$10.00
$8.00
Cache discount
90% off
75% off
Context
1M
1.0M

Quality

Task confidence comparison

Confidence score from zero to one hundred by task type, where higher is better.
Code Generation
68
vs
0
Code Review
96
vs
0
Summarization
64
vs
0
Q&A
89
vs
0
Extraction
70
vs
0
Reasoning
89
vs
0
Classification
86
vs
0
Creative Writing
62
vs
0
Claude Sonnet 5
GPT 4.1

Guidance

When to use Claude Sonnet 5 vs GPT 4.1

Choose Claude Sonnet 5 when...

  • Similar performance; consider provider preference or ecosystem fit.

Choose GPT 4.1 when...

  • -You need a larger context window (1.0M vs 1M)
  • Similar performance; consider provider preference or ecosystem fit.

At scale

Cost at scale

Estimated cost assuming a seventy percent input and thirty percent output token split.
Claude Sonnet 5
GPT 4.1
100K tokens
$0.44
$0.38Cheaper
1M tokens
$4.40
$3.80Cheaper
10M tokens
$44.00
$38.00Cheaper

FAQ

When should I use Claude Sonnet 5 instead of GPT 4.1?

Claude Sonnet 5 and GPT 4.1 perform similarly across all tracked tasks. Pick based on pricing and provider preference.

Is GPT 4.1 cheaper than Claude Sonnet 5?

Both models have the same input pricing at $2.00/MTok. Compare output pricing: $10.00 vs $8.00/MTok.

What are the context window sizes for Claude Sonnet 5 and GPT 4.1?

Claude Sonnet 5 has a 1M token context window. GPT 4.1 has a 1.0M token context window.

Track your real costs

Comparisons show estimated costs at list price. The dashboard reveals your real spend and savings.